User ID Tracking vs Logged In Custom Dimension

Looking to track the activities of your logged in users of your website? MonsterInsights offers two types of user tracking: User ID tracking with the built-in Google Analytics feature and user tracking by setting up a custom dimension.

In this article, we’ll explain two types of visitor tracking offered by MonsterInsights, as well as the differences you’ll find between a Universal Analytics (UA) property and a Google Analytics 4 (GA4) property with regards to User ID tracking.

Not sure which Google Analytics property type you have? Read about the differences here: Google Analytics 4 Versus Universal Analytics

You’ll find:

What is User ID Tracking in Google Analytics?

By default, Google Analytics identifies every user of your website by assigning them a unique ID known as Client ID in UA properties. In GA4 properties, this is referred to as App Instance ID.

This ID is a unique, randomly generated string and gets stored in a site visitor’s cookies, which helps identify represents the unique device from which users engage with your content.

You’ll find Client IDs in your UA property at Audience » User Explorer.

You’ll find App Instance IDs in your GA4 property in the Explorations » User Explorer page.

This means if a unique user browses through your website from two different devices, it will be counted as two different users, not a single user.

By enabling User ID tracking with MonsterInsights, you can track individual logged in users more accurately even if they visit your site from different devices. This way, you can accurately track the engagement data of each unique user of your website and discover how they interact with your content from different devices and multiple sessions over an extended period of time.

How does MonsterInsights User ID Tracking Work?

Instead of using the Google Analytics Client ID or App Instance ID, MonsterInsights uses the unique WordPress User ID of each individual user, so you can easily keep track of logged in users in your Google Analytics reports.

To find the WordPress User ID of your users, just go to your WordPress dashboard and click on Users » All Users.

Then, locate the user you want to find the ID for and click the Edit link.

You’ll see the User ID in the web address or URL while viewing the edit page for that user. The parameter is labelled as user_id.

find user ID in the URL

MonsterInsights replaces the anonymous Client ID or App Instance ID with this WordPress User ID with just a few clicks.

Refer to this guide to learn how to enable user tracking in Google Analytics.

How to Find the User ID Tracking Report in Google Analytics

If you have a UA property, once you’ve enabled User-ID tracking, make sure you are in the correct View while at This View is normally named UserID.

Then you can find the User ID tracking report by navigating to Audience » User Explorer in your Google Analytics account.

You can click on the User ID to see more detailed info on each user.

If you have a GA4 property, you can go to Explorations and click into your existing User explorer report.

If you haven’t made a User explorer report yet, you can click on the right arrow () on the page to scroll to the template User explorer (normally found to the most right of the page) and click on it to create one.

In your created User explorer report, you’ll be able to see the App Instance ID replaced with a User ID.

If you click into the User ID, you’ll open another tab titled User activity 1 and be able to view more details on that individual site visitor and their activity.

What is Logged In Custom Dimension?

The Logged In custom dimension keeps track of whether your visitors are logged in to your site or not. However, it doesn’t track individual users.

How to Set Up Logged In Custom Dimension Tracking

You’ll have to set up a custom dimension with Logged In as a dimension type using our Custom Dimensions addon.

For more help, you can learn how to set up custom dimensions.

How to Find the Logged In Dimension Report in WordPress

Prerequisites: You will need to have the Pro Tier or higher of MonsterInsights installed.

Step 1: Navigate to Insights » Reports » Dimensions.

Step 2: Select the desired date range.

Step 3: Scroll down to your logged in sessions report.

How to Find the Logged In Dimension Report in Google Analytics

You can create your custom dimension report by creating a custom report in Google Analytics if you have a UA property.

If you have a GA4 property, you can find custom dimensions inside of your reports.

Your report will show you whether your visitors are logged in to your site (“true”) or not (“false”).

User ID Tracking vs. Logged In Custom Dimension

Below are a few differences between User ID tracking and Logged In Custom Dimension.

  • Individual User Tracking: With User ID tracking, you can track the activity of each individual logged in user separately. However, the Logged In custom dimension only allows you to view logged in vs. not logged in visitors as a whole.
  • Setup: To set up User ID tracking, you don’t need to use any MonsterInsights addon whereas to set up Logged In custom dimension, you’ll need to install Custom Dimensions addon.
  • Finding Report in Google Analytics: You can find the report for User ID tracking only in the User Explorer page in your UA or GA4 property. However, with Logged In custom dimension, you can easily create a custom report in your UA property or add an extra column parameter when viewing detailed reports in your GA4 property.

We hope this guide helped you to learn the differences between User ID tracking and Logged In custom dimension.

You might also want to set up site search tracking, which provides you important insights on user interaction.